Moment of Truth Read online

  “What the fuck?” Jack said, enraged, and suddenly everybody was in motion.

  Trevor bolted in panic for the door, pushing Whittier out of the way. Jack lunged for Trevor but the teenager had enormous momentum and knocked him backward. He darted out the door, and Jack recovered and ran after him, his heart pounding. Jack wasn’t about to let Trevor get away. He’d catch up with Whittier later.

  Trevor thundered down the hall, a strapping kid in sneakers, but Jack ran quicker, fueled by a father’s rage. He heard shouting from the reception area at the hall’s end. He couldn’t explain it and didn’t try. Trevor bounded for the reception area with Jack right behind him, panting heavily.

  “Stop, Trevor!” Jack shouted. He narrowed the gap between them, reaching for Trevor’s sweatshirt, then veered around the corner. The sweatshirt was almost within Jack’s fingertips when the elevator doors opened and a cadre of Philadelphia police flooded the reception area. Cops? Where had cops come from? What the hell was going on? Jack skidded to a bewildered stop but Trevor ran practically into the arms of the cops.

  “He’s got a gun!” Trevor screamed. “He’s trying to kill me!”

  “Freeze!” one of the cops ordered, drawing his gun on Jack.

  “I’m unarmed!” Jack shouted, but in the next instant a crazed Trevor grabbed the gun from the cop’s hand.

  “No!” yelled the cop, jumping for his weapon. The cop flanking Trevor grappled for it, too, and they were wrestling for the gun when it went off, the sound reverberating hideously in the tony corporate setting. Jack held his breath and didn’t know if anyone had been hit. Neither did the cops. And for a final split second, neither did Trevor.

  “Shit!” said one of the cops, pained and angry, when the gun dropped to the plush Oriental.

  Jack watched in horror as a strange smile appeared on Trevor’s face, then went suddenly slack. Bright red blood spurted from a round hole in his neck, under his chin. His eyes rolled back in his head and he collapsed silently against the cops, who sprang instantly into action, trying to save his life. One palmed a radio while another ran to the reception desk for a phone. Two knelt over him, checking for a pulse and trying to staunch the flow of blood.

  Jack, aghast, rushed to Trevor’s side and knelt down beside the cops. Blood was everywhere, spurting regularly with each heartbeat, and they couldn’t seem to stop it. They fell silent, their drawn faces acknowledging what they couldn’t say. Even Jack could see how much blood Trevor was losing and hung his head over the boy’s body.

  “Shit, it’s arterial,” said the cop at Trevor’s neck. Blood gushed through his fingers despite his grip. Trevor’s face was ashen and his blue eyes still.

  “The carotid,” the other cop said, his voice heavy with regret. “Oh, jeez. Oh, jeez.”

  Jack couldn’t believe it was happening. The kid was dying. He shook his head over his body, then spotted something. Trevor’s shirt had been pushed up in the struggle and a purplish bruise peeked from the elastic bottom. Jack reached out and pressed his shirt to the side. My God. Bruises blanketed Trevor’s stomach. It had to be the bruises Mary had told him about, that hadn’t been on Paige. Jack was looking at the man who murdered Honor.

  “No,” he said, remembering Whittier, in a horrified daze. He had to make him account for this. And for Honor, and Paige. He rose to his feet but when he stood up his arms were grabbed from behind, wrenched together, and slapped into tight handcuffs. “What are you doing?” Jack demanded, twisting around in anger.

  “Take it easy, Newlin,” a cop ordered, shoving him to the elevator.

  “I didn’t do anything! I don’t have a gun—”

  “We’ve been looking for you. We’re taking you down for questioning in the attempted murder of your daughter.”

  “What? Me, kill Paige? Are you insane?” Jack struggled against the handcuffs but more cops appeared. This was a nightmare. Him suspected of trying to kill Paige. Trevor bleeding on the floor. Whittier getting away with murder. “You can’t stop me, you have no right! Get Whittier, would you? Arrest him! He’s behind this and the murder of my wife!”

  The cops shoved him toward the elevator. “Tell the detectives about it when you get there,” one said.

  “How dare you, Jack!” came Whittier’s voice, from the entrance to the reception area. Jack twisted around in the cops’ grasp, but Whittier remained composed, slipping into the pinstriped jacket he’d been carrying. “That’s libel, and if you repeat it I’ll sue you and the paper that prints it.”

  “Sue me, you asshole!” Fury constricted Jack’s throat and he lunged for Whittier. The cops yanked him back and the handcuffs dug into his forearms. They shoved him toward the elevator but he stood his ground. “This boy’s dying because of you! My wife died because of you! And my daughter—”

  “Enough!” Whittier shouted. “As I told the officers, this boy, as you call him, has been blackmailing me over you. He told me you have been trafficking in cocaine, with his assistance—”

  “That’s a lie!” Jack shouted. He resisted the cops but they edged him to the elevator bank.

  “ — he was threatening to go to the press with it, destroying my law firm.” Whittier’s tone quieted in the face of Jack’s rage. “You must have known he’d be meeting me tonight, here, and that’s why you—”

  “Bullshit! You and Trevor killed my wife! You tried to kill my daughter!” Hearing himself raging, even Jack knew Whittier looked and sounded the more believable of the two. And he didn’t have a murder charge hanging over his head. It infuriated Jack all the more. “I’m on to you, you asshole!”

  “ — came to my office, to kill him. You’ve lost control, Jack. You need help. Counseling. Are you an addict, too? You’re not the man I knew.”

  “He’s lying!” Jack erupted, lunging again for Whittier. He almost slipped free but the police tackled him to the rug, grunting and shouting. The wound on his cheek erupted and pain shot through his ribs. He thrashed and fought back to get to Whittier, but the cops subdued him.

  “Get the fuck down!” they shouted. “On the floor! Get down!” They rained blows on his arms and legs. His ribs exploded in renewed agony.

  Jack torqued his body right and left to get free, screaming Whittier’s guilt until his ranting ended with a blow to the head and everything went black.

  53

  Mary peeked through the wired window of the interview room at the Roundhouse and felt her heart wrench in her chest. Jack sat cuffed to a steel chair that was bolted to the floor. A goose egg with broken skin swelled over his right eye and the wound on his cheek gaped. Blood dotted his tourist jacket and he slumped in the chair, in obvious fatigue and pain. Only his eyes had any life in them and they brightened the moment she opened the door.

  “Jack!” she said, rushing into the grimy room. She didn’t throw her arms around him, but knelt to be eye-level with him and touch his shoulder. She’d given up any pretense of sounding lawyerly, and his expression told her he had decided that he wasn’t only a client anymore.

  “Can I hire you back?” he asked, with a smile that reached her almost as deeply as a hug. A cut on his lip cracked when he grinned. “Now that I know you’re from a nice family and all.”

  “You got it,” she said, flushing with pleasure, then recovered her wits. They were alone in the interview room but it had a two-way mirror with a videocamera. The cops and maybe even Davis were on the other side. Mary leaned closer to Jack so they couldn’t be overheard. “They want to question you. The D.A. is convinced you were the one shooting at Paige. He had the cops looking for you. Let’s just lay it out, okay? The whole truth and nothing but.”

  “It’s about time,” Jack whispered. “The inheritance has to be why they think I tried to kill Paige. I don’t benefit under Honor’s will but I do under the trust, if Honor is dead. Get to Whittier. He’s the executor in both and the fees are worth millions to him and the firm. That’s all I’ve got to go on.”

  “Don’t worry.” Mary stood up
and faced the mirror, her hand on Jack’s shoulder. It was warm and strong beneath her fingertips, or maybe it felt good to acknowledge her feelings for him. “Olley, olley, oxen free,” she called out, and in the next minute, the door to the interview room opened and in came Detectives Kovich and Donovan.

  Kovich took the chair across from Jack, and Donovan stood against the wall. Mary didn’t wait for a Q & A and laid out the truth about Jack falsely confessing to the murder and about Trevor killing Honor and telling Paige she did it. Jack picked up the story about Trevor’s being the one in the ski mask and his theory about Whittier being behind the murder. Mary noticed they both omitted Brinkley, to keep him out of trouble.

  Kovich listened intently, but Donovan scowled throughout the account. “So, Mr. Newlin, you want us to believe that one of your partners, William Whittier, was in a conspiracy with Trevor Olanski to kill your wife and daughter?”

  “Yes,” Jack said, straightening in his chair with obvious discomfort. “That’s what’s going on.”

  “Sir, why would a partner in an important law firm conspire with a high school drug dealer?”

  “I don’t know that, I can’t explain that myself. I was going to find out when I was brought here and I still can. Why don’t you ask Whittier that question?”

  Kovich looked concerned behind his overlarge aviators, but Donovan pursed thin lips. “We did question Mr. Whittier, and the story he told us is very different from yours.”

  “What did he say?” Jack’s tone turned angry. “More crap about this supposed blackmail and cocaine scheme?”

  “I’m not at liberty to discuss it with you, but we’re investigating it. It conflicts directly with what you just told us.”

  “I’m not surprised, but what I’ve told you is true.”

  “That’s what you said at your confession, as I recall. I saw the video.” Donovan shoved his hands deep in the pockets of his fashionable black pants. “You said you were telling the truth then, but now you tell me it was all a lie. And your daughter, who went to Captain Walsh and said she was telling the truth, then later said she was lying, too. You put your own daughter up to protect you?”

  “Of course not,” Jack snapped. “We’ve explained it to you. You don’t want to believe us, there’s no way we can convince you. Trevor is dead now, so we can’t ask him.” He edged forward on the steel chair, his handcuffs pulled tight. “Let me go and I’ll prove it to you.”

  “I don’t think so. You’re here to answer our questions,” Donovan said, though Kovich appeared not to have any. “Where were you when Paige was shot at? We place the time of the incident at about six o’clock.”

  “I was trying to find her. I knew she was in danger from Trevor.”

  “Where exactly did you go to find her?” Donovan asked skeptically. “I assume we can verify who you talked to.”

  Mary knew the detective was getting into the time period when Jack was with Brinkley. She wondered if Jack would tell the detectives about him. It would help Jack’s cause but put Brinkley on the hook. Taking evidence from a crime scene; interfering with a police investigation. They could charge Brinkley with obstruction of justice.

  “Mostly I called around, from my hotel,” Jack answered, and Donovan snorted in derision.

  “You were so worried about your daughter that you picked up the phone and made a few calls?”

  “It was my only option. I would have gone to look for her but I didn’t know where to start, and I wasn’t free to walk around the city, not with the press after me everywhere I went.”

  “Got it.” Donovan nodded, and if a nod could be sarcastic, this one was. “So you sat in your hotel room and called people. Who did you call?”

  “Her apartment. A few photographers.”

  Jack was making it up as he went along, and even Mary could see it. He wouldn’t betray Brinkley, and though she admired him for it, she considered doing it herself. The choice between Jack and Brinkley wasn’t an easy one, but there was no way Donovan would believe them now anyway. Exposing Brinkley wouldn’t accomplish anything but hurting him.

  “So you made some calls to photographers,” Donovan was saying. “What did you find out?”

  “Nothing. I didn’t reach anybody. I left messages everywhere I could.”

  “Did you call nine-one-one, like you did after you killed your wife?” Donovan shot back, but Jack kept his cool.

  “I told you, I didn’t kill my wife. And no, I didn’t call nine-one-one about Paige.”

  “Why not, if you thought she was in mortal danger?”

  “There wasn’t time and I thought I could handle it myself.”

  “Why would you think that, Mr. Newlin? You have police training? Firearms, self-defense, and whatnot?” Donovan cocked a thin eyebrow, and Mary guessed he was trying to learn if Brinkley was involved.

  “No training, but she’s my daughter. I was the one who put her in jeopardy. I was the one who was going to get her out of it.”

  “By making phone calls?” Donovan half smiled. “That means your phone records at the hotel would back you up.”

  “Yes they will,” Jack answered quickly, though Mary knew they wouldn’t. It was time to interrupt.

  “Detective,” she said, “you’ve asked enough questions to make it clear you have no evidence to support a charge of attempted murder against Mr. Newlin. It’s the middle of the night, and Mr. Newlin is exhausted and in need of medical attention. This fishing expedition is over. Release my client.” Mary rose to her feet, but Donovan stepped forward.

  “Ms. DiNunzio, you don’t tell us when we’re done, we tell you. Your client is on bail for a murder charge. Now he’s a suspect in an attempted murder of someone who may be a witness at his trial. So we got him on the attempt, obstruction charges, and witness tampering. We can hold him until we check his phone records and we will.”

  Mary and Jack exchanged looks. They both knew it was true, and in the morning the D.A. would probably have Jack’s bail revoked. He’d be in prison until the trial, unless she could free him. Mary was on her own again, without him. She had come full circle. But it was different now, for lots of reasons. Not the least of which was that she was certain of his innocence and that her attraction to him had become undeniable, maybe even mutual.

  “So I agree with you, the interview is over. But you’re the one who’s leaving, Ms. DiNunzio.”

  Mary rose to her feet. “You want to question Mr. Newlin further, you call me first. Nobody goes near him without me there. You get him the medical attention he needs. In the morning I’m filing a motion with the court complaining of police harassment.”

  “Somehow I knew you would say that,” Donovan shot back, and Kovich got up and opened the door.

  Mary noticed he avoided her eyes when she walked out.

  Dwight Davis stood with Captain Walsh on the other side of the two-way mirror. Davis felt fresh despite the late hour, but Walsh rested an arm wearily against the molding around the mirror, which looked onto the interview room like a window. “This case is gonna kill me,” the captain said wearily, watching Kovich recuff Newlin through the window. “I don’t work this tour anymore.”

  “Lighten up, Cap.” Davis grinned, his legal pad hugged to his chest. He watched the two-way mirror as if it were great TV. “We caught Newlin in another lie, and as soon as I talk to the Chief, he’ll pick up an attempted murder charge. I gotta find a way to get this before a jury. This man is going down big-time.”

  “Newlin’s not the problem,” Walsh said under his breath, but Davis picked it up.

  “Who then?”

  “What?”

  “Who is the problem?”

  Walsh sighed. “Brinkley.”

  “Brinkley?” Davis’s neat head snapped from the window. “You think he’s helping them?”

  “I can handle it.”

  “Shit!” Davis was pissed. The fuckin’ cops. From time to time he had to remind them who ran the show. Unlike lots of D.A.s, he didn’t kiss up to t
he department. “Cap, I’ll be straight with you—”

  “Hold the lecture, counselor.”

  “No. If I find out that Brinkley had anything to do with Newlin or DiNunzio, I’ll charge him with aiding and abetting, accessory after the fact, anything I can find. I will not have a rogue cop undermining my prosecution.”

  “Brinkley’s not a rogue cop, for Christ’s sake,” Walsh shot back.

  “Get him in line, or I will,” Davis said, and walked out.

  54

  It was early morning when Mary hit the sidewalk outside the Roundhouse and waded into the throng of media. Despite the cold, their numbers had swelled from the night before. Trevor’s death and Jack’s arrest had whipped them into a frenzy. They mobbed her, clicking motor drive cameras, screaming questions, and thrusting videocams and bubble microphones into her face. They fogged the air with steam and filled it with noise and action.

  Mary put her head down and barreled ahead, remembering TV footage she’d seen of her boss, Bennie, running the same gauntlet. Odd to think she was doing it now, too. Was this really her? And was it progress? Wasn’t she really better off whining about her job? Reading the classifieds? Daydreaming about the life of a manicurist? At least on this case, she knew the answer.

  She ran to the corner. She knew she couldn’t get another cab and she hadn’t convinced the one that had brought her here to wait. Brinkley couldn’t risk coming out in daylight to pick her up, and so she’d had to plan ahead. She had, by checking the schedule. The white SEPTA bus rumbled by, this one spray-painted all over with DEGAS AT THE ART MUSEUM, and she ran for it, her briefcase bumping at her side.

  The bus genuflected at the bus stop, a misnomer if there ever was one, but the pause did give her time to be seen in the driver’s rearview mirror. The sight of a passenger running flat out usually cued SEPTA buses to zoom away, but this one stayed put. Either it took pity on her because of the media after her like a swarm of killer bees, or the driver didn’t know the rules. She caught up with the bus, her chest heaving in the cold air. Its doors folded apart with a familiar rattle-and-slap, and she grabbed the steel handrail and leapt aboard. In Philly, real lawyers rode buses.